Homegrown My Ass Vol.4
Prior to the mid-70s in Canada and Australia, local music was hardly played on their radio stations. Perception of domestic music was poor. Around that period, several groups of individuals and record labels bandied together and drew up white papers to lobby their respective governments to foster a domestic music industry. The primary point was radio airplay. If you don't get to hear it, no one is going to know it. Newspaper, mags, print media might rave about this band and that singer, but music is heard, not read. If the masses don't hear it, no matter how many rave reviews your band gets, its not going to make a rat ass difference.
The main plan was to work towards a minimum quota of local music that radio stations must have on their playlist. If I'm not wrong, it was a 4 or 5 year plan. Beginning with Year One, 10%. Year Two 20% or something like that and going into 40% at the end, This is to allow the industry players to slowly have an infrastructure in place (staffing, fine-tuning their A&R, etc).
Sounds great right? But no. When the idea was first mooted, there were heavy resistance against it. Radio stations and advertisers didn't warm to the idea, that the public is used to American Top 40. It's too much work. So why rock the boat? Even the masses would (I imagine) go "eeee local music sucks" (sounds familiar right?). But both Canada and Australia's government then push it through and became mandatory law for radio stations have that quota in their playlist.
At end of the 4 or 5 year plan, it started to reap rewards. In the early 80s, both countries saw real $$$$ growth in their domestic music industry. So much so that there was a huge surge in Aussie bands making inroads into the American Top 40- INXS, Men At Work, etc. The same goes for Canadian music with bands like Men Without Hats. It created jobs (engineers, producers, A&R staff, etc etc). With that it created expertise. The more they do it, the better they get. With expertise, it attracts jobs/projects/businesses from overseas. Get the idea now? Beyond all this, I reckon is the most important intangible...
P R I D E.
It's priceless. National pride is something you cannot tag a $ value to it. It gives a profound sense of meaning to every individual in relation to the geographical space they call home. So often I've seen/spoken to Canadians and Aussies whose eyes will have that extra gleam whenever the pub/club plays something from their country. This is the result of what happened in the mid to late 70s in their countries.
Can it be done here in Singapore?
(Note: My info was accumulated from talking to overseas colleagues when I was working in record companies years ago. And also through the years of reading here and there.)
I can't get enough of 1234X. So here's(live) two more.
At the same gig was Destroy All Monsters. 1 vox, 1 bass and a mean drummer. Real kick ass stuff.
Wish I can hangout more with Aidil from Couple who is such a nice fella. They were here a few weeks ago and played a marvellous set. I told him that the opening guitar lines for Tentang Kita always make me gush. And I thought Say Hi was Stay High... I'm so silly.
The main plan was to work towards a minimum quota of local music that radio stations must have on their playlist. If I'm not wrong, it was a 4 or 5 year plan. Beginning with Year One, 10%. Year Two 20% or something like that and going into 40% at the end, This is to allow the industry players to slowly have an infrastructure in place (staffing, fine-tuning their A&R, etc).
Sounds great right? But no. When the idea was first mooted, there were heavy resistance against it. Radio stations and advertisers didn't warm to the idea, that the public is used to American Top 40. It's too much work. So why rock the boat? Even the masses would (I imagine) go "eeee local music sucks" (sounds familiar right?). But both Canada and Australia's government then push it through and became mandatory law for radio stations have that quota in their playlist.
At end of the 4 or 5 year plan, it started to reap rewards. In the early 80s, both countries saw real $$$$ growth in their domestic music industry. So much so that there was a huge surge in Aussie bands making inroads into the American Top 40- INXS, Men At Work, etc. The same goes for Canadian music with bands like Men Without Hats. It created jobs (engineers, producers, A&R staff, etc etc). With that it created expertise. The more they do it, the better they get. With expertise, it attracts jobs/projects/businesses from overseas. Get the idea now? Beyond all this, I reckon is the most important intangible...
P R I D E.
It's priceless. National pride is something you cannot tag a $ value to it. It gives a profound sense of meaning to every individual in relation to the geographical space they call home. So often I've seen/spoken to Canadians and Aussies whose eyes will have that extra gleam whenever the pub/club plays something from their country. This is the result of what happened in the mid to late 70s in their countries.
Can it be done here in Singapore?
(Note: My info was accumulated from talking to overseas colleagues when I was working in record companies years ago. And also through the years of reading here and there.)
I can't get enough of 1234X. So here's(live) two more.
At the same gig was Destroy All Monsters. 1 vox, 1 bass and a mean drummer. Real kick ass stuff.
Wish I can hangout more with Aidil from Couple who is such a nice fella. They were here a few weeks ago and played a marvellous set. I told him that the opening guitar lines for Tentang Kita always make me gush. And I thought Say Hi was Stay High... I'm so silly.


25 Comments:
Hi Joe,
This is Mark from KL, former member of Huang Huo Productions, not sure whether you still remember me, we met few years ago when you visited our place with Sam Seen.
Check out our latest project:
www.soundscape-records.com/dirtythree
I heard similar stuff about the Austrailia/Canada radio quota too, but you probably know more.
I'm thinking it might not work as well now since music buying has fallen. And I don't listen to the radio anymore, not for a long, long time. Radio has become irrelevant for the indiekid.
The whole scene has changed, the internet is more powerful as an influence now. More blogs, myspace pages and forum chats would probably get more attention placed on local music than radio.
Perhaps more could be said about where to buy these cool local music, I only know of Earshot at the Arts House that stocks lots of local stuff.
i love the idea. well, the radio and everything aside at this point... (reading what little said which is quite true as well)...
but what hit me is the result of it creating not than just jobs, but expertise.....
The local music quota in Oz and Nz does NOT work.
Around the early to mid eighties was a healthy time for music worldwide. Acts sold millions and millions of records and this had a flow on through all the english speaking music markets and each country had a very healthy local music scene. Drink driving laws were lax, a pint of beer didnt cost an arm and a leg and a pub could put on a band without having a multitude of licences and modifications to cut down noise. An office job in those days really was over by 5pm and life was a lot simpler. This was healthy for the music scene which produced acts like Cold Chisel and Split Enz.
If you go to Oz or NZ now, radio stations fill thier quota by playing EXACTLY the same music they did in 1985. Cold Chisel, Men at Work, Split Enz. This is helping no one. In NZ I would swear they stopped making music around 1991 because every time I turn the tv on to watch the rugby what are they playing at the ground? Some hot new act? Nope, a hit single from at least 15 years ago.
The recent rugby league final in Sydney showcased INXS playing new sensation and the Hoodoo Gurus playing Like Wow Wipeout...both songs from 80's.
The irony is that bands like Chisel, INXS, Split Enz etc didnt kick start thier career by having a quota. They were around for a long time, writing great songs and playing smoky pubs night after night to hone thier craft. They were massive live acts with huge followings before the radio had a quota imposed on them and when the quota appeared, radio stations knew exactly what they were going to play to meet it.
Remember Sydney is a city the size of Singapore but there was a scene which was much bigger than Singapore could ever hope to be. No venues, no mass market music media, small followings, a diverse multi lingual market....having a quota won't fix that.
Having a quota in Sg would typify the local population in that it is placing an expectation on the government to help bands of mediocre talent, poor songwriting and even worse production skills be played on the radio as though it's a right. Great bands like Split Enz and crowded house didnt have this, in fact Crowded House was dismissed entirely in NZ until they had a number 1 single in the US as was Savage Garden in Oz. They ahd to go away and prove to the rest of the world how good they were before radio would play any of thier stuff back home. Some of the Chinese artists here have the same problem.
Some of the bands here are working thier butts off towards it and it's paying off...Electrico? they dont seem to have a problem being played on the radio.....
Anyway, who listens to the radio anymore?
Good music is good music, whether its on the radio or not.
I agree with you on 'pride'. It sure feels different supporting my favourite foreign band by buying their cd, and watching my favourite local bands live.
The way the media potrays it these days makes it seem like the perception of local music is getting better. But its not really true, or is it?
[PS: you have to answer me this question. do you print your t-shirts yourself? where then? they're great!]
Pop Idol counted anot? Although it is pop music, can it be a foot in the door at pushing local music?
Tend to agree with anonymous based on experiences in my home country with respect to imposed quota :
1) To reach the imposed quota radio stations would need to start playing mediocre music in order to reach the quota which means that quantity takes priority over quality
2) The local bands that made a name for themselves did so thru hard work and not because their music was being aired on the radio.
3) Listening to the radio in some of our neighbouring countries (Spain for example – which has an imposed quota) drives you crazy due to the lousy quality of the music
4) In some other European countries (France and Germany) they have dedicated radio stations that play 50% good quality local music.
5) Stimulating your own music/culture should not be done thru imposing a quota but by allowing more non commercial initiatives
I would rather be prepared to hear both 60% of shit local music and discover 40% of talented local music, then to have never known the 40% existed at all because nobody wanted to give them a chance.
k
Angshu from the Ocean Band posted a comment recently but somehow it didnt appear here. I shall split it into two parts.
Angshu comments part 1:
Joe,
It's very nice reading your passionate take on the music scene in Singapore.
A couple of things:
1) I'm not sure forcing a quota on radio stations will help local music very much in the long run. In my experience, a quota leads to a short term boost in the "industry" (such as that is), but it is not a translatable currency - it holds no real value and is not a worthwhile measure of success.
What I mean is this. For a band, making it to the radio on a quota offers little more than the temporary gratification of hearing their song getting airplay. However, it's a bit like the handicapped parking slot. Put this on your presskit and take it to the UK or the US, and it will be a taint more than anything else.
Ultimately - and this is very, very important - the music itself MUST stand up, without endorsements, without context, without references. That is the only way to get more exposure, especially internationally.
2) Having said all this, it is also true that there is a certain prevalent mindset in Singapore whereby people prefer "international" acts over local ones, with such absurd outcomes as a way-past-their-prime Rolling Stones filling up a stadium at hundreds of dollars a seat where ye olde band from Clementi will have their work cut out for them to get fifty people into a bar at a ten dollar cover charge.
The fact that the Sembawang Festival in January bombed so massively was a harsh lesson - people simply aren't going to listen if you don't already have a name and it's near impossible to get an international name here, so it's a vicious circle.
The fact of it is gig-going (as the concept exists in Europe and the US) is a novelty here. People as a rule do not want to spend their Friday nights with a band that they have never heard before in a sweaty, smoky no-name bar. It's not worth it when it's much more comfortable just heading down to a comfy, popular club playing covers of familiar material. It's a shame, methinks, but there we are and changing mindsets takes years.
Here's part2:
3) What The Suns did is perhaps the only thing left to do. I'm of the opinion that Singapore lacks the critical mass to launch a band to anything higher than getting their picture in 'Banter'. If a name has to be earned, it has to be earned somewhere where there are significantly more gig-goers (and I can't begin to emphasise how important gigs are for exposure, and how much more valuable they are than the radio - people remember gigs they go to).
What can local bands do, in the face of something potentially this disheartening?
I would say record. Record, and jump at any chance to play and not stop at any costs. It's easier to record and get your music on the net than ever before. There's a whole world of terrific independent small bands out there. Join the club. Book shows in neighbouring countries. Success isn't about magazines and airplay. Success is about lots of people enjoying your music for what it is. Work like hell, and things will happen. They will happen slowly because that's how it is. Don't rely on the fleeting success of getting into something by virtue of being "homegrown". Rely on effort and persistence.
That having been said, the scene here is certainly a good deal better than it was even five years ago. Things are beginning to move and this is always good news.
Angshu (The Ocean Band) originally posted this on at 10/14/2006 04:44:51 PM.
Not true about music quota not being filled.
stations like triple J, which i listen to alot, play plenty of local Australian music. The local music tv programme for free to air tv, RAGE, and on music programmes on cable tv like MTV and Channel V, all play plenty of music videos by Australian bands and the Aussies are lapping it up. For every single international act that plays in Australia, there is usually an Austrlian act opening for them, And honestly, the music scene here is bustling.There is great pride in the local scene but this has come from years of allowing local aussie music to fill the airwaves.
I think its an exciting time for Singapore now with all the localbands getting exposure from the internet radios and blogs and whatnot, however, it is only limited to a select few listeners. It is quite important that the scene continues to grow with support from Singaporeans.
It is not true that Australian radio plays solely cold chisel, split enz, and big bands from the past so i will have to disagree with anonymous, here's a website for a local radio station in Australia and you can see for yourself the amount of local bands that get airplay. Some of them ARE quite rubbish but still... exposure of their bands from their own country help to breed a thriving music scene in Australia.
http://www.abc.net.au/triplej/events/ausmusicmonth/
whilst a short term boost by placing a quota on airplay for local bands may seem to only lead to "a short term boost in the industry",it also fulfills the role of making Singaporeans aware that there are quality musicians in the country. With regards to lessons learnt from the Sembawang festival, it bombed mostly because many of the artists he initially invited to play were displeased with his management. The fans of these bands simply did not wish to go to an event that disrespects the local community.
interesting donald should mention triple j, for that was the radio station which played singaporean hardcore band My Precious and did and interview with one of their singers when the band toured australia last sept.
when i saw them on Broadway in Sydney, they were easily the best band on that night, even thou zul told me later that show was the worst of their whole tour.
quality ?
and in a way this all feeds back into angshu's point abt the need to tour outside singapore....
interesting donald should mention triple j, for that was the radio station which played singaporean hardcore band My Precious and did and interview with one of their singers when the band toured australia last sept.
when i saw them on Broadway in Sydney, they were easily the best band on that night, even thou zul told me later that show was the worst of their whole tour.
quality ?
and in a way this all feeds back into angshu's point abt the need to tour outside singapore....
yo joe,
i know i don't write many comments in your blog... but this song i really like. current favourite. it's by a Thai band called Venus Butterfly... they remade a song by Boyd. here are both versions. one at Youtube and the other at ethaimusic.com
chekkit!!
http://www.ethaimusic.com/lyrics3/713.htm
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=flEasPLzhUc
oops. not sure if you got the first post.. here's another link to my current favourite song..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=flEasPLzhUc
and
http://www.ethaimusic.com/lyrics3/713.htm
oops. not sure if you got the first post.. here's another link to my current favourite song..
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=flEasPLzhUc
and
http://www.ethaimusic.com/lyrics3/713.htm
Guess you found yourself a friend on power 98. Mario was making a similar plead on the radio this (Monday) morning.
Yup, everything's online nowadays I hardly listen to the radio anymore. I suppose only those with cars still do listen to the radio. The internet has opened up a whole means of self publicity.
joe where are you?
joe are you there?
damien@gorgeous-productions.com
9015 4724
eh joe start posting lah. * slap ur ass*
I,m a spanish lost in translation in singapore.
i love pop music and i would like to know any place to go at night.
i read about cosmo cafe, it is open? can anyone suggest me something...any event, concert...etc....?
Thanks..
Artista por confirmar
all i can say is we now have The Observatory. goodbye to mediocre. hello world fookin' beaters.
i know pool has taken over your life, but the masses are waiting...
Post a Comment
<< Home